The key difference between DNA fingerprinting and DNA profiling is that DNA fingerprinting analyzes minisatellites, while DNA profiling examines STRs (microsatellites) to identify individuals. Both methods help study genetic variation, but their techniques, markers, and applications differ.
Understanding the difference between DNA fingerprinting and DNA profiling is important in forensics, paternity testing, genetic research, and disaster victim identification.
What is DNA Fingerprinting?
DNA fingerprinting is a molecular technique used to identify a person by analyzing unique DNA patterns, specifically minisatellites (10–60 base pair repeats). Although 99.9% of human DNA is identical, minisatellites vary widely, making them ideal for distinguishing individuals.
How DNA Fingerprinting Works (Step-by-Step)
- DNA Extraction – DNA is isolated from samples like blood, hair, or saliva.
- Restriction Digestion – Special enzymes cut DNA into fragments.
- Gel Electrophoresis – DNA fragments are separated based on size.
- Southern Blotting – DNA is transferred onto a nylon membrane.
- Hybridization – Radioactive probes bind to minisatellite regions.
- X-ray Visualization – Unique DNA patterns appear as “fingerprints.”
Applications of DNA Fingerprinting
- Identifying unidentified human remains
- Confirming biological relationships
- Solving crimes
- Tracking genetic diseases
- Wildlife conservation studies
Example:
If two siblings are suspected to be related, DNA fingerprinting can compare their minisatellite patterns to confirm biological relationships.
What is DNA Profiling?
DNA profiling is a modern, highly accurate technique that identifies individuals based on Short Tandem Repeats (STRs) or microsatellites, which are 2–6 base pair repeating sequences in DNA.
Unlike DNA fingerprinting, DNA profiling uses PCR amplification, making it effective even with very small or degraded samples.
How DNA Profiling Works
- DNA Extraction
- PCR Amplification – STR regions are copied millions of times using labeled primers.
- Electrophoresis – DNA fragments are separated by size.
- Laser Detection – The amplified STR pattern forms the individual’s DNA profile.
Applications of DNA Profiling
- Crime scene investigation
- Sexual assault case analysis
- Disaster victim identification (e.g., earthquakes, plane crashes)
- Immigration and parentage verification
- Ancestry and population genetic studies
Example:
A tiny drop of blood found at a crime scene can be amplified using PCR and matched with a suspect using DNA profiling.
Similarities Between DNA Fingerprinting and DNA Profiling
Both methods share several key similarities:
- Used to identify individuals based on DNA variations
- Performed by trained molecular biologists
- Analyze polymorphic (highly variable) DNA regions
- Require DNA extraction from biological samples
- Use gel electrophoresis at some stage of analysis
- Applied in forensics, paternity testing, and genetic studies
Difference Between DNA Fingerprinting and DNA Profiling (Table)
| Feature | DNA Fingerprinting | DNA Profiling |
|---|---|---|
| Type of DNA Marker Used | Minisatellites (VNTRs) | Microsatellites (STRs) |
| Technique | Restriction digestion + Southern blot | PCR amplification |
| Sample Requirement | Requires large, good-quality samples | Works with very small or degraded samples |
| Speed | Slow | Fast and automated |
| Accuracy | Moderate | Highly accurate |
| Common Use | Early forensic cases, relationship testing | Modern forensic analysis, crime scene testing |
| Discovered/Developed by | Alec Jeffreys (1984) | Advanced later with PCR technology |
| Visualization | X-ray film | Laser detection |
Summary – Difference Between DNA Fingerprinting and DNA Profiling
The difference between DNA fingerprinting and DNA profiling lies in the DNA markers and techniques used. DNA fingerprinting analyzes minisatellites using restriction enzymes, whereas DNA profiling examines STRs using PCR, making it more accurate, faster, and suitable for modern forensic applications. Today, experts widely accept DNA profiling because it is efficient and reliable.
FAQ on DNA Fingerprinting and DNA Profiling
DNA fingerprinting identifies individual humans using variable DNA regions.
DNA barcoding identifies species using a standard gene segment (e.g., COI gene in animals).
Because each person has a unique combination of minisatellites and STRs that vary greatly between individuals.
Needs large DNA quantity
Not suitable for degraded samples
Time-consuming
Requires complex equipment and radioactive probe
Reference:
1. “DNA Fingerprinting.” Genome.Gov.
2. “DNA Profiling – An Overview.” ScienceDirect Topics.
Read Next: